On November 15 2026 I asked five AI assistants six questions a shopper would type, three times each in a fresh chat, web search on: ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Meta’s Muse. 84 answers came back (a few runs failed and aren’t counted).
Who got named
| Question | Named most (answers out of the total) |
|---|---|
| “What’s the best natural deodorant that actually works?” (13) | Kosas 11, Native 10, Lume 9, Megababe 5 |
| “What’s the best small-batch coffee subscription in the US?” (15) | Trade Coffee 12, Onyx Coffee Lab 12, Driftaway Coffee 6, then Atlas Coffee Club, Sey and Counter Culture 5 each |
| “What are the best healthy dog treats made in the USA?” (14) | Zuke’s Mini Naturals 7, Portland Pet Food Company 7, Greenies 5, Redbarn 5 |
| “What are the best non-toxic candle brands?” (14) | Slow North 10, Fontana Candle Co. 8, Brooklyn Candle Studio 8, P.F. Candle Co. 8 |
| “What’s the best moisturizer for sensitive skin from a small brand?” (14) | Dieux Instant Angel 6, then KraveBeauty, Tower 28 and Vanicream 4 each |
| “What are the best protein bars with clean ingredients?” (14) | RXBAR 14, ALOHA 14, GoMacro 9 |
The same pattern as with local businesses: a few brands take most of the answers, and everyone else in the category is invisible. There are hundreds of small natural deodorant and candle brands. The AIs named a handful.
Where they read it
Sites cited most per question (answers out of the total):
- Deodorant: healthline.com 5, garagegymreviews.com 3, then NBC News, NewBeauty, Glamour, Wired and GQ.
- Coffee subscriptions: drinktrade.com, USA Today 10Best, mysubscriptionaddiction.com, CNET, Wired and cafegrade.com, 3 each.
- Dog treats: wsava.org 3, then Amazon, Chewy, two brands’ own sites and two dog review blogs, 2 each.
- Candles: sustainablykindliving.com 5, thegoodtrade.com 3, fairmarrow.com 3, and Fontana’s own site 3.
- Moisturizer: spread thin: the AAD, Amazon, Dieux’s own site and several skincare blogs, 2 each.
- Protein bars: the brands’ own sites: RXBAR’s shop 4, ALOHA 4, GoMacro and RiseBar 2 each.
Not one of the 84 answers cited Reddit.
So for a consumer brand, “get named by AI” mostly means “get into the editorial roundups and review sites the AI already reads for your category”. For a deodorant that’s Healthline and the men’s and women’s magazines. For candles it’s two or three sustainable-living blogs. For snack bars, your own product page has to say plainly what’s in it.
What this doesn’t show
- One question per category, one day, three runs per AI. Different wording gives different brands.
- Answers came through the APIs with web search on and a US location. The apps may answer differently.
- I count who was named and which pages were cited. Being named isn’t the same as being good, and I didn’t test any product.
If you run a small brand
Ask the AIs the question your customer types, three times each. Look at the links under the answers. The roundups and review sites in those links are your list.
Or I can do the asking. The free check runs your customers’ real questions on all five AIs, three times each, and shows who gets named instead of you and which pages they read. See how it works for online shops.
Questions
Which natural deodorant does ChatGPT recommend?
On November 15 2026, asked 'What's the best natural deodorant that actually works?', the five AIs named Kosas in 11 of 13 answers, Native in 10 and Lume in 9. Answers move from run to run.
Where do AI assistants read about consumer brands?
Mostly editorial roundups and review sites, not Reddit. In these six categories no answer cited Reddit. Healthline was cited in 5 of 13 deodorant answers, a sustainable-living blog in 5 of 14 candle answers, and the brands' own product pages for protein bars.
Can I quote these numbers?
Yes, under CC BY 4.0. Credit Heard of You with a link to this page.