On November 15 2026 I asked five AI assistants the question a person new to town would type: who is the best dentist, med spa, personal injury lawyer, roofer, AC repair company and plumber in Fort Lauderdale. ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Meta’s Muse, each question three times, web search on.
That’s 90 answers. Here is who got named, and where the AIs read it.
How I ran it
One plain question per trade, written the way people actually ask, with “Fort Lauderdale, FL” in it. Each AI got each question three times in a fresh conversation, so 15 answers per trade. I counted an answer as naming a business if the business’s name appeared in it anywhere, and I read the lists by hand.
This is one day, one question per trade. Answers move from run to run, so read it as a snapshot of who the AIs reach for, not a ranking.
Who got named
Out of 15 answers per trade:
| Trade | Named most | Named in | By which AIs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dentist | Florida Smiles Dental | 10 | ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Muse |
| Fort Lauderdale Family Dental | 7 | ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity | |
| Premier Smile Center | 6 | Gemini, Muse | |
| JJ Dental | 5 | Gemini, Muse | |
| Med spa (Botox) | The Beauty Clinic | 12 | all five |
| Las Olas Med Spa | 5 | Claude, Muse | |
| Amaira | 5 | Gemini, Muse | |
| Personal injury lawyer | Englander Peebles | 7 | Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, Muse |
| Kelley Uustal | 7 | Gemini, Perplexity, Muse | |
| Bradley Winston | 5 | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Muse | |
| Roofer | Tiger Team Roofing | 10 | all five |
| Paul Bange Roofing | 4 | ChatGPT, Gemini, Muse | |
| LaPorta Roofing | 4 | Gemini, Muse | |
| AC repair | Quality Air Conditioning | 7 | Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, Muse |
| Six companies tied | 6 each | Pride Air Conditioning, Fort Lauderdale AC Services, Cool by Design, Comfort Zone Air Conditioning, COOL AIR USA | |
| Plumber | Paradise Plumbing | 11 | all five |
| Mike the Plumber | 6 | Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, Muse | |
| John’s Plumbing | 6 | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Muse |
(AC repair has five names at 6, listed together.)
The pattern is the same in every trade. One or two businesses get most of the mentions, and the AIs disagree about the rest. In five of the six trades, the top business was named in at least 7 of 15 answers. Everyone else in town, and Fort Lauderdale has hundreds of dentists and plumbers, was named in a handful or none.
Four more Florida cities
The same day I asked the dentist and med spa questions about Miami, Tampa, Orlando and Boca Raton, word for word with the city swapped. 15 answers each:
| City | Dentist named most | Med spa (Botox) named most |
|---|---|---|
| Miami | Gables Sedation & Family Dentistry 10, Gables Family Dental 5, Beach Smile Family Dentistry 4 | Monaco MedSpa 10, SkinSpirit 5 |
| Tampa | Playa Family Dentistry 9, South Tampa Dentistry 6, Doering Family Dental 6 | ÉLAN Aesthetics 7, Vein & Cosmetic Center of Tampa Bay 6, Faces of South Tampa 6 |
| Orlando | Mosaic Dental Center 9, Buena Vista Family Dentistry 7, Gordy Family Dental 6, Overmeyer Family Dental 6 | Nectar Aesthetics 10, LightTouch Med Spa 6 |
| Boca Raton | Boca Family Dental 6, Regency Court Dentistry 6, Dental Care of Boca Raton 6 | Peace Love Med 10 |
Same shape everywhere: one practice in the 9 to 10 range, then a handful named a few times each.
Where the AIs read it
Every one of the 90 answers cited sources. The sites that came up most, per trade (answers out of 15):
- Personal injury lawyers: expertise.com 7, avvo.com 4, bestlawyers.com 4, floridabar.org 3.
- AC repair: expertise.com 7, then a spread of company sites and homeguide.com, homeadvisor.com 3 each.
- Plumbers: consumeraffairs.com 8, bestinhood.com 6, angi.com 5.
- Roofers: bbb.org 5, homeadvisor.com 3, thisoldhouse.com 3, expertise.com 3.
- Dentists: bestinhood.com 6, dentistsranked.com 5, birdeye review pages 4, zocdoc.com 4.
- Med spas: the top med spa’s own site 5, then a long tail of local magazines and finder sites.
So for a local business, “get on the lists the AI reads” means a short, specific list per trade. A lawyer needs Expertise.com and Avvo. A plumber needs ConsumerAffairs and Angi. A roofer needs BBB.
The part that surprised me
Claude cited throwaway directory sites, hosted for free on developer platforms, in 7 of its 18 local answers. Three of them were for plumbers, from a site called plumber-directory-v6, and three from one called best-plumber-in-american-samoa. For a question about Fort Lauderdale.
The other four AIs didn’t cite any of these.
I’m not saying anyone should build one. I’m saying the bar for “a page Claude will read” is lower than people think, and a real business with a clear page and real reviews should clear it easily.
ChatGPT’s new business listings
OpenAI opened Businesses in ChatGPT on November 10 2026. It’s free. An owner claims the business, verifies it, and fills in the profile, and the dashboard then shows how often ChatGPT mentioned the business. According to BrightLocal and PPC Land’s coverage, storefront businesses can claim an existing US listing now, and service-area businesses (the ones that drive to you, like plumbers and roofers) are listed as coming soon.
If you run a dental office, a med spa or a law office in Fort Lauderdale, it’s worth claiming this week. I wrote up how I set up my own.
What this doesn’t show
- One day, one question per trade, 15 answers each. Different wording gives different names.
- Answers came through the APIs with web search on and a US location. The ChatGPT app on your phone may answer differently, and it knows where you are.
- I count who was named and which pages were cited. I can’t see why an AI picked them, and being named is not the same as being good. Several excellent businesses I know of weren’t named at all.
If you run one of these businesses
Ask the question your customers ask, on more than one AI, three times. Write down who gets named and which sites the AI cites. Then get onto those sites with real reviews, claim your ChatGPT listing if you have a storefront, and make sure your own site says plainly what you do, where, and for whom.
Or I can do the asking for you. The free check runs your customers’ real questions on all five AIs, three times each, and shows who gets named instead of you and which pages they read.
Questions
Which dentist does ChatGPT recommend in Fort Lauderdale?
On November 15 2026, asked 'Who is the best dentist in Fort Lauderdale, FL? I need a new family dentist.' three times each, the five AIs named Florida Smiles Dental in 10 of 15 answers, Fort Lauderdale Family Dental in 7, Premier Smile Center in 6 and JJ Dental in 5. Answers change from run to run.
Which websites do AI assistants read to recommend local businesses?
Mostly directories and review sites, and they differ by trade. Expertise.com was cited in 7 of 15 answers for personal injury lawyers and 7 of 15 for AC repair. ConsumerAffairs in 8 of 15 for plumbers. BBB in 5 of 15 for roofers. Claude also cited throwaway directory sites hosted for free, in 7 of its 18 answers.
Can I quote these numbers?
Yes, under CC BY 4.0. Credit Heard of You with a link to this page.