# What 5 AIs actually recommend: 60 checks on small businesses

I asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Meta's Muse buyer questions for 60 small businesses, three times each. 4,364 answers: 36 of the 60 were never named, and each AI reads different sources.

By Dasha. Updated November 14 2026. https://heardofyou.io/research/what-5-ais-recommend-60-checks

Over the last two weeks I wrote 60 reports for small businesses. For each one I asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Meta's Muse the questions a buyer would type, three times each, and counted who got named.

That's 4,364 answers. Here's what was in them.

## How I ran it

For most businesses I wrote five questions from their own website: a "best X for Y" question, one with a price cap, a "what do people like me use" question, an "alternatives to the big name" question, and a plain problem with no product words in it. When a founder gave me the exact question their buyers type, I used it word for word.

Each question went to each AI three times, with web search on and a US location. 51 checks used all five AIs, 75 answers each. The first 9, from October 31, used four, 60 answers each, because Muse joined the next day.

The businesses were not random. Most are small software products I found on launch day, or founders who asked me for a check. A few aren't software: a freight broker, a permit drawing service, a property guide site, a travel site. New and small, on purpose. Read the numbers as a floor, not a market rate.

## Most of them were never named

36 of the 60 were named in zero answers. 48 were named in two or fewer.

Across all 4,364 answers, the business I was checking came up 132 times. That's 3.0%.

And the 132 aren't spread evenly. Three businesses hold 65 of them. The best single result was an Etsy seller tool, named in 39 of 75 answers. Most of the rest weren't at the table.

When an AI did name one of them, it nearly always recommended it: 122 of the 132 times. So the problem is rarely being described badly. It's not being mentioned.

## Somebody else was always named

In 59 of 60 checks, the most-named rival came up more often than the business. The top rival appeared in a median of 57% of answers.

Add it up and the top rivals got 2,572 mentions. The businesses got 132.

Almost every answer named someone. The only question was whether it was you.

## Which AI names small businesses

On the 51 checks that used all five:

| AI | Named (of 765 answers) | Businesses named at least once (of 51) |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 34 | 13 |
| Muse | 33 | 13 |
| Gemini | 23 | 4 |
| Perplexity | 10 | 4 |
| Claude | 8 | 3 |

ChatGPT and Muse named small businesses most. Claude named them least. Gemini's number leans on one business: take it out and Gemini drops from 23 to 12.

The bigger point: of the 20 businesses named at least once, 9 were named by exactly one AI. If you test one assistant and call it done, you've tested one assistant.

## Where they read

This part surprised me more than the scores.

Reddit showed up as a source in 49 of the 60 checks. That sounds like "go post on Reddit". But it was cited in only 205 answers, and 143 of those came from Gemini. Claude cited Reddit in 0 of the 262 answers where it cited anything. Muse, 0 of 562.

Review sites work the other way round. G2 or Capterra was in about 1 in 5 of Claude's cited answers (57 of 262). For ChatGPT it was about 1 in 100 (9 of 894).

List articles mostly mean Claude. When Claude put links in its answer, at least one was a "best", "top", "alternatives", "vs" or "review" page 68% of the time (189 of 280). For ChatGPT it was 6% (55 of 894). ChatGPT mostly linked to product pages directly.

The same tool-list sites turned up across unrelated categories: toolradar.com in 28 checks, alternativeto.net in 22, sourceforge.net in 21. Wikipedia came up in 4.

So "where should I get mentioned" has a different answer per AI. Gemini reads Reddit. Claude reads review sites and roundups. ChatGPT reads the vendors' own pages.

## Your own site still counts

Of the 132 answers that named a business, 99 also cited that business's own website. That's 75%.

In 32 of the 60 checks, the business was named zero times and its site was cited zero times. The AI never got there at all.

The Etsy tool that got 39 of 75 had its own site cited in 32 answers. One ChatGPT answer quoted the plan prices straight off its pricing page. Plain facts on a page an AI can read look like the entry ticket. Not the whole show. The ticket.

## Ask three times

I asked every question three times per AI. Where a business was named at least once (72 cases), it was named in all three runs only 21 times.

The first product named was the same across all three runs in 37% of cases.

So if someone sends you one screenshot of ChatGPT recommending them, that's one draw from the hat.

## The founder's question beat mine

Twice, a founder sent me the exact question their buyers type, and I ran it again.

One was a no-code app builder: zero on my five questions. On the founder's own question it came up in 4 of 15 answers. Muse put it first in all three of its answers, each time citing the founder's own guide.

The other was CollectIQ, run by Kinecia Wheeler, who said yes to being named. Her first check found her pricing and about pages returning "page not found". She sent four questions in her own words, and the one she said mattered most was the one where an AI picked her product. The same evening she put up seven pages.

Two cases. A story, not a rule. But it's why I now ask every founder for their buyer's exact question.

## What this doesn't show

- No before and after yet. Re-checks are planned for December.
- Answers came through the APIs with web search on. The app on your phone may answer differently.
- 60 hand-picked, mostly new businesses, five questions each. Different questions would give different numbers.
- I count what was named and what was cited. I can't see why.

## What I'd do with this

Ask the AIs your buyers' real question, three times each. Write down who got named and which pages they read. Make sure your own site says the plain facts: what it is, who it's for, what it costs. Then go where your buyers' AI reads, which isn't the same place for every AI.

I'd love to say there's a trick. So far there's a list.

The numbers on this page are free to quote under CC BY 4.0, with a link to this page. Want the same check for your own business? It is free: five questions, three runs, five AIs, 75 answers.

## Questions

**How often did AI assistants name the small businesses checked?**

Rarely. Across 4,364 answers for 60 small businesses, the business was named 132 times (3.0%). 36 of the 60 were never named at all, and in 59 of 60 checks the most-named rival came up more often.

**Does posting on Reddit help a business get named by AI?**

Mostly for Gemini. Reddit was a source in 49 of 60 checks, but 143 of its 205 citations came from Gemini. Claude cited Reddit in 0 of 262 answers that cited anything, and Muse in 0 of 562.

**Which sources does each AI read?**

They differ. Gemini leaned on Reddit. Claude leaned on review sites and roundups: G2 or Capterra in 57 of its 262 citing answers, and a best, top, alternatives, vs or review page in 189 of 280 answers with links. ChatGPT mostly linked to vendors' own pages.

**Can I quote these numbers?**

Yes, under CC BY 4.0. Credit Heard of You with a link to this page.

